When signing Camp David treaty between Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and Prime Minister of the Zionist entity Menachem Begin on 1979, some scholars loyal to the State claimed that this treaty - which stirred opposition and attack by the Egyptians and Muslims in general and Muslim scholars in particular - is similar to Hudaibiya truce, since it is a victory for Muslims though apparently it is inequity and oppression for Egyptians. They claimed that Muslims will avail from Camp David like the Prophet Muhammad and Muslims benefited from Hudaibiya truce. Is it really so?

In fact, extremely is the similarity between Camp David and Hudaibiya truce, but unfortunately it is a reversely one, since the Muslims in Camp David were in the place of polytheists in Hudaybia truce as for loss results of the treaty, where as the Zionists were in the place of the Prophet Muhammad and Muslims in terms of advantages.

No wonder, the first advantage of Hudaybia truce for Muslims was that the recognition of Quraish for them, hence all the Arabs recognized the state of Islam in Medina; After years of hostility and war on Islam by Quraish, and after years of holding Muslims renegades, Quraish signed a treaty with such dissidents. This means Quraish acknowledges their state, their ability to fulfill their accords, and fear their power, so it averts their confrontation and hold truce with them to mass troops.

On the contrary, inCamp David; the Zionist entity was condemned since formed on 1948 A.D and no Arab state acknowledged it, though the west did. However, Camp David made for the first time the recognition ofIsraelby a Muslim Arab state, rather the senior one. It wasEgyptwhere all the Arabs hold valuable and copy it, and no Arab state can take a decision of war or launch it withoutEgypt. It ranks first to the Arab states in terms of military and human force and it struggled in vigor against Zionists since its establishment in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973 wars.

In consequence of this, Camp David represented a very significant advantage for Zionists, becauseIsraelthrough the next years gained recognition from the Arab states openly and in secret. Accordingly, political, cultural and commercial Zionist relations strengthened with some of the Arab regimes and their subordinates. By signingCamp David,Egyptcompletely distanced from conflict with the Zionist enemy and its borders with Zionists became the safest and the most stable.

The Prophet Muhammad punished Quraish for breaking its treaty when it allied with Bani Bakr tribe and assaulted Khuza`ah tribe, the ally of the Prophet, by openingMecca. Therefore, the case in Camp David is completely different where Zionists daily break the treaty by penetratingEgypt's airspace and bombing it many times leaving dead civilians, police forces or border guards whileEgyptfails to take action. Why?

This is because Sinai is divided longitudinally to three sections; called from eastward to westward A, B and C.

(A) Section: is the area between Suez canal and A area in 58 km width, and Egypt is allowed there to be armed with one mechanized infantry squad consisting of 22000 soldiers, with arming limited to 230 tanks and 126 artillery guns on the ground and 126 anti-aircraft gun caliber 37mm and 480 vehicles.

(B) Section: located eastward section A with 109 km width and limited to 4000 Border Guard soldiers with light weapons.

(C) Section: located between the world borders eastward and section (B) westward and any Egyptian forces are banned to be there save police forces. Also the establishment of any military airports or ports in all of Sinai is banned.

In exchange for these restrictions inEgypt,Camp Davidrestricted the Zionist entity only in the region (d), which is located west of the international border and only 4 km width, and 4000 soldiers. This means that the enemy's army can break into the Sinai by crossing 4 km, while our military needs to cross 140 km to reach their borders. How a humiliation forEgyptis that?!

Doubles this shame is that this state is for lifetime as cited in the treaty, unlike to Hudaybia which was appointed to 10 years.Camp Davidtreaty is humiliating Muslims, since it is indefinite in time, and thus it restricts us, except if they break it and definitely will do. The Jews always break their accords and cheat their allies, as Allah (Exalted is He) says: ( Is it not [true] that every time they took a covenant a party of them threw it away? But, [in fact], most of them do not believe.), Al-Baqara, 100.

The big question is to be ready for a day when they break the treaty to do the same when the Prophet opened Mecca.

Are we ready to open Jerusalem?!

https://islamstory.com/en/artical/3407647